Mired in secrecy, the uranium market hopes to someday offer price transparency. To whom will this real uranium price become transparent? Industry insiders know well before the general investing public ever finds out.
Utility fuel managers compete with a few handfuls of fuel brokers for the best price break. Utilities complain about the unwelcome speculators whove entered the market. and utility spokesman predict a long-term price about one-half of the US$122/pound price indicator announced in Nuclear Market Review this past Friday (another consulting service chose $125/pound for their price indicator). Some uranium miners forecast a price racing past $200/pound. Who is gaming whom? Or is this all part of the negotiations process between producers and end-users?
Meanwhile, more immediate price transparency seems to appear at Mestenas regular spot uranium price auctions than in the much larger, but secretive uranium marketplace. Yet, the amount this private uranium producer has sold is far less than one percent of the uranium consumed in 2006. The present spread between spot and long-term uranium pricing has raised eyebrows and led some to question the credibility of the spot price.
Mestenas next auction reportedly takes place on May 30th, or at least thats when offers to buy the U3O8 are due. This time Mestena will have a bit of competition. An unnamed hedge fund has contacted potential buyers to solicit offers for 200 thousand pounds U3O8 and 100 metric tons U as UF6 two days after Mestena opens the magic envelopes. As more material is offered to the market, perhaps the spot and long-term price will narrow to a more logical spread. Perhaps, instead, this spread will close when utilities and investors reach a consensus on Cameco Corps (CCJ) Cigar Lake project, Rio Tintos (RTP) Namibian expansion and resolution of the March flooding in northern Australia, and a firm date on BHP Billitons (BHP) Olympic Dam expansion.
A Glimpse Inside This Secret World
The widely heralded fiat uranium trading at the highly publicized NYMEX ring moves forward, but the exchange is still searching for participants, and it is about as entertaining as watching grass grow. In lower Manhattan, this commodity exchange was not only the first commodity forum to offer trading on platinum more than 40 years ago, but in early May began offering paper uranium trading. The public can play the paper chase, but not for the real McCoy U3O8.
In mid-town Manhattan, near Grand Central Station, a lesser known commodity exchange, run by New York Nuclear, has real-time screen trading every Wednesday morning between 7:30 A.M. and 9:30 A.M. And the screen trading is for the real thing the physical delivery of U3O8. The processed uranium is offered for delivery within a 30-day period at a licensed uranium conversion facility. Real product trading in real-time by real professionals, who mine uranium, consume uranium or act as a broker for either side.
No, the public is not invited to this clubby function. One must be a certified market participant to bid for or sell U3O8 through New York Nuclears Uranium Online. While NYMEX paper trading is open to amateurs and professional traders, Uranium Online only permits recognized persons to bid or offer uranium for sale.
We have all categories as players, New York Nuclears Joe McCourt told StockInterview.com. Those who have signed up to trade physical uranium on his online screen system include uranium producers, hedge funds, fuel brokers and utility fuel managers. These are the major players in the physical uranium market, McCourt added.
Our chat with Joe McCourt was quite enlightening. Later in an email exchange with Uranium One (SXRFF) chief executive Neal Froneman, we were told Joe is a heck of a nice guy. Others in the industry echoed his sentiments.
In a few words, Joe explained why uranium price transparency is presently out of reach, and could remain a mythical goal for some time. Theres so few players in the business, and theres a lot of confidentiality, McCourt told StockInterview. Everybody wants to see what everybody else does, but they dont want anybody to see what they do.
McCourt has also observed this secrecy in his companys online screen system trading of physical uranium. Everybody wants to see everybody elses posts, but they dont want to post themselves, he told us.
Surrounded by this degree of secrecy and the recent NYMEX competition, why does McCourt persist? In my opinion, I think that utilities want transparency, he told us. We want to improve how the market works.
So who participates in the weekly trading sessions? These are people we know to be bonafide buyers and sellers, McCourt said. And what makes these bonafide? We are in touch with the major players. Weve been in the business for 25 years, and weve done deals with many people. We know who is for real and who is not for real. (See Joe McCourt end bio.)
How does McCourt screen out the gamers? We have user agreements, rules and procedures that everybody signs, he told us. Its a contract. When anybody posts something in the system, its a like valid offer. They make a commitment.
Do the buyers and sellers know with whom they are dealing? No, its anonymous, McCourt said. Only we know. We stand as the hub. They can see us, but they cant see each other. McCourt reassured us his system has kept permanent records of all transactions and discussions during those trading sessions. We have a system that is auditable, if some authority comes to us, he said.
Another concern was his companys participation in the trading. We dont do it on our own account, McCourt told us. We are strictly brokers. We are matching buyers and sellers. Its our reputation thats on the line.
Prior to participation in the online trading, everyone on the system is sent a possible counterparty list. Those companies who have had bad relationships in the past can strike off parties with whom they will not do business. People are very concerned about credit, McCourt explained. You dont want to sign a deal with someone you dont like their credit, or you dont think they are a reliable supplier. He further explained that risk departments are very involved with procurement these days and companies are very careful about their counterparts.
What are the bugs in McCourts system? Most material is bought and sold under long-term contracts, he said. Theres not a long of activity in the spot market. We are trying to help more activity develop in the spot market by making it easier for people to do deals, having certain delivery times and delivery locations. In other words, McCourt hope to standardize the secondary market.
But why is there only one two-hour trading session per week? Theres not a lot of liquidity in this market, McCourt responded. We picked two hours once a week to concentrate on this. Otherwise, its like watching paint dry.
New York Nuclear has only completed one transaction since launching this late last year. Why? For large companies, this is something new, he explained. It has to go through reviews, legal reviews, risk management reviews and all that. Its a departure from what they normally do. In other conversations weve had with utilities and industry insiders, this is the problem NYMEX faces in drawing utilities into trading on their exchange.
Still, McCourts action impacted NYMEX trading this past week. After screen trading was completed last Wednesday, the NYMEX June 2007 U3O8 uranium swap suddenly dropped. During the previous week, McCourts screen snapshot, published in his Thursday night edition of FreshFUEL showed June 2007 uranium at $122 and December uranium at $130. This past Wednesday, uranium for December delivery dropped to $125/pound.
No transactions took place. But, it does confirm that buyers would be willing to pay $122 to $125/pound to purchase U3O8 for June and December delivery. Sellers refused to part with their material. Five days later, Ux Consulting raised the firms weekly spot price indicator to $125/pound. Obviously, TradeTech decided on the front-month and made the judgment call of $122 in this Friday edition of Nuclear Market Review, while Ux Consulting decided upon Decembers delivery month price.
As a fuel broker, which is New York Nuclears main business, McCourt said, As far as spot volume is concerned, I dont think anyone knows everything thats going on. He pointed out his company has been doing transactions off the screens. We dont publicize those transactions, he told us. And true to his word, McCourt did not reveal the pricing on his companys transactions.
McCourt hopes he can grow his online trading business by attracting more buyers and sellers to post on his screen system. We are helping the buyers and sellers get together so eventually these screens will be populated with a lot of numbers, and hopefully a lot of transactions. McCourt also pointed out, Thats going to add tremendous transparency to this market, which doesnt exist to a great extent now. He hopes utility buyers can make routine, small purchases instead of infrequent large purchases. Instead of buying one million pounds every year, they could buy 20,000 pounds every week, McCourt said.
Conclusion
Over the past year, the combination of a sharp uranium price rise accompanied by the entry of new uranium producers has probably obscured price transparency instead of providing more transparency.
Aside from finding out why there is now a $37/pound spread between the spot and long-term contract price for U3O8, we have one significant unanswered question. At which levels are the escalating floor prices for the recent contracts announced for the near-term U3O8 production by companies such as Paladin Resources (PALAF) and Uranium One? Until we gain a better understanding of these floor prices, we may not realistically have price transparency.
In the interim, investors and traders can have some glimpse of price transparency but only for short-term trading purposes. In a previous article, we evaluated some of the available market research tools available to the sophisticated investor.
http://stockinterview.com/journal.htmlLets put this into a linear timeline for better understanding.
The first company out of the box with any indication of where the uranium market could head during the current week and into the early part of the following week is New York Nuclear. Wednesdays screen trading includes utility fuel managers, fuel brokers, utility risk managers and other buyers, who square off for two hours, early Wednesday morning, against their counterparts. These could include other fuel brokers, uranium producers or their marketing managers, hedge funds and speculators. To date, price indications are provided as to what buyers could be willing to pay for U3O8 purchases, and at which prices sellers wont part with their material.
Granted, little transaction activity has taken place on the Uranium Online trading screens, but the activity during those screen trading sessions provides some price guidance. On Thursday night, Washington Nuclear (sister company of New York Nuclear) emails the weekly edition of FreshFUEL to paid subscribers. In the past two issues weve reviewed, a screen shot is provided on Page 2. The companys tutorial can be found on its website at www.uranium.com.
Late Friday night each week, TradeTech publishes changes in the spot price in Nuclear Market Review. TradeTech interviews its proprietary list of market participants on Friday afternoon and gathers new data not reported in FreshFUEL. Because the market participants in the Wednesday screen sessions are mostly North American and European, TradeTech may obtain new data or find out about off-screen transactions post-Wednesdays screen trading. A new weekly spot price is reported on TradeTechs website at www.uranium.info
Every two weeks, Platts Nuclear Fuel is published for the nuclear industry. In the May 21st edition, one of three front page headlines reported, Two uranium auctions expected to push U price up. Spot price transactions, according to traders Platts interviewed, were expected to reach between $120 and $140/pound U3O8. Because Platts emails its newsletter to paid subscribers on Friday before TradeTech issues its weekly spot price, Platts subscribers get the old price.
Sometime on late Monday, Ux Consulting reports its spot uranium price to paid subscribers. On a few occasions there have been negligible discrepancies between the UxC price and the TradeTech weekly spot price. Late Tuesday, non-UxC subscribers find out this consulting firms price indicator.
The next day, on early Wednesday morning a new cycle begins when New York Nuclear conducts the next session of its screen trading.
For all the hoopla, little uranium price transparency has taken place with NYMEX futures. Ux Consulting president Jeff Combs announced it would take about six months or so to develop. Its the or so part we believe may take longer than Mr. Combs expects. In the way of an apology, NYMEX suggested this tiny amount of trading was what was expected.
NYMEX faces the same hurdles New York Nuclear has yet to overcome. Risk management departments at utilities question whether or not they will participate in these futures. Of those weve had conversations with, we are told, We are still studying this.
Between New York Nuclears Wednesday screen trading of physical uranium (as opposed to paper trading) and TradeTechs weekly report on the spot uranium price, we obtain some guidance as to the direction of the uranium market.
But this only provides short term visibility. Until the long-term uranium price and the spot price narrow the spread, and until price transparency comes about from the escalating floor contracts, the general public will remain in the dark.
A real solution would come from physical uranium trading on a grand scale, as Joe McCourt envisions, instead of the fiat trading now taking place.
COPYRIGHT © 2007 by
http://StockInterview.com James Finch contributes to StockInterview.com and other publications. He has contributed to the widely popular Investing in the Great Uranium Bull Market, and Uranium Outlook 2007 - 2008. His recent work, Investing in Chinas Energy Crisis, is now available at
http://bookstore.stockinterview.com/Renae Blog16914Oralla Blog20130
